Common Mistakes New Silver Investors Make & How to Avoid Them
- Phoebe Dao
- Apr 24
- 3 min read
Updated: Apr 25
Silver has always had a certain allure—beautiful, tangible, and historically a reliable store of wealth. But like any investment, it comes with a learning curve. At R and P Bullion, we’ve seen the full spectrum of silver buyers: from savvy stackers to first-time enthusiasts. And time after time, we see new investors stumble on the same avoidable mistakes.
Here’s our comprehensive guide to the most common silver investment missteps—and how to steer clear of them.
1. Focusing Only on the Spot Price
The Mistake: Believing silver should be bought or sold at spot price alone.
The Fix: Understand that the spot price is the base value of silver, but physical silver always comes with a premium—covering manufacturing, minting, and dealer costs. Compare total prices before making a decision.
2. Ignoring the Importance of Liquidity
The Mistake: Buying obscure or ultra-niche silver products that may be hard to sell later.
The Fix: Stick with recognised, trusted brands and mints—like Royal Mint, Germania Mint or New Zealand. These tend to hold resale value and are easier to trade.
3. Neglecting Storage and Security
The Mistake: Accumulating physical silver without a secure plan for where to keep it.
The Fix: Consider your options—home safes, bank vaults, or secure storage through reputable providers. Insured storage gives peace of mind.
4. Going All In Too Quickly
The Mistake: Putting a large amount of money into silver without testing the waters.
The Fix: Start small. Get familiar with the market. Learn how premiums work. Understand what types of silver appeal to you most—bullion, bars, collectables or junk silver.
5. Falling for “Too Good to Be True” Deals
The Mistake: Buying silver from unverified websites or sellers offering deep discounts.
The Fix: Do your due diligence. Stick with licensed dealers who clearly list premiums, policies, and contact information. If it seems dodgy or too cheap, it probably is.
6. Not Diversifying Your Silver Portfolio
The Mistake: Only buying one type of silver product, like all coins or all bars.
The Fix: Mix it up. Bars are cost-effective for bulk stacking. Coins offer legal tender and collectability. Rounds are a fun middle ground. A diverse mix gives you flexibility and balances resale options.
7. Overlooking Tax Implications
The Mistake: Assuming all silver investments are tax-free.
The Fix: Know your local tax laws. In some regions, silver is subject to VAT or capital gains tax. Speak with a financial advisor or ask your bullion dealer what to expect.
For example: Britannia coins are completely free of capital gains tax because they are coins of the realm and therefore legal tender.
8. Confusing Collectable Value with Bullion Value
The Mistake: Paying a high premium on collectable or themed coins expecting bullion-like returns.
The Fix: Separate your collector mindset from your investor mindset. Some coins are bought for love, not profit—and that’s okay! Just be clear about what you’re buying and why.
9. Panic Selling During Dips
The Mistake: Selling off silver during price drops out of fear.
The Fix: Understand silver is volatile in the short term, but historically strong long term. Be patient. Stick to your investment plan. Remember—smart stackers don’t panic.
10. Not Asking Questions
The Mistake: Staying silent out of embarrassment or inexperience.
The Fix: Ask! No question is too small. Whether it’s about premiums, storage, or how to start, our team at R and P Bullion is here to help with honest advice and real knowledge.
Final Thought
Silver investing is a journey. You’ll learn as you go—but you don’t have to learn the hard way. With the right approach and a trusted dealer by your side, you can build a portfolio that’s solid, secure, and smartly managed.
At R and P Bullion, we’re not just here to sell—we’re here to guide, support, and empower.
🔍 Shop our silver coin and silver bar collection
📞 Contact us via info@randpbullion.com for advice or availability
